This working paper contributes to the identification of the legal principles, arguments, jurisdictions and, in general, the conditions under which it may be fitting to explore and push the limits of judicial enforceability of the progressive realisation of ESCR in national, regional and international judicial and quasi-judicial bodies, including the European Committee of Social Rights.

The paper argues that at least the following criteria should be taken into account when pursuing litigation in relation to the progressive realisation of ESCR:

  • Whether the legal obligation of progressive realisation exists in the first place, either as direct recognition in national law or via incorporation of international human rights law.
  • Whether the case can be articulated as a violation of an immediate obligation or minimum core obligation underpinning progressive realisation, such as the obligation to take steps and the obligation not to discriminate.
  • The level of concreteness of the positive obligation to realise ESCR progressively.
  • The existence, pros and cons and possible use of earmarking as a budgetary tool.
  • The possible extension of principles and practices already embraced by judges to the realm of progressive realisation – principles and practices that will vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.
  • The timeframe in which steps to the maximum of available resources were taken or not taken.
  • In the case of domestic litigation, whether the State accepted the jurisdiction of an international monitoring body, to which the case could be submitted after exhausting internal remedies.
  • The key role of civil society as leaders and galvanisers of an associated campaign or as providers of information relevant for the case and/or its implementation.

Access the document here: https://cbeh.cat/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/CBEH-Casla-et-al-2025-strategic-litigation-progressive-realisation-ESCR.pdf